Pat Buchanan sums up his point of view in two succinct sentences (lamenting the supposed de-unification of America):
One part of America loves her history, another reviles it as racist, imperialist and genocidal. Old heroes like Columbus, Stonewall Jackson and Robert E. Lee are replaced by Dr. King and Cesar Chavez.
Yeah, the horror. Instead of school children across America honoring the life and times a general who fought against the United States, Stonewall Jackson, they are forced to honor that scoundrel communist Martin Luther King Jr.
Of course America is divided. When you have rightwing bigots like Pat Buchanan holding up secessionist generals as their heroes, ignoring the various Presidents and military brass who have worked hard over the centuries to keep us united, its no wonder there is a segment of America who sees disunity at every corner.
But America has long been divided in various aspects, be it racially, culturally, economically, or geographically. There have been times when Northern states ran roughshod over the South, and times when the South prevailed and the North sat quietly on their hands. There have been times of liberalism and conservatism. Secularism and fervent religious activism. With the exception of a four year period in the 1860s, we've stood together.
So what makes things different? Buchanan mentions abortion, but that issue has been far more divisive in years past than today. While people in many parts of the country still oppose the term "gay marriage," almost across the board people have warmed to the notion that gay couples should be able to live their lives in peace, and be afforded similar rights to straight married couples, if not the name itself. Hell, it was only about 6 years ago that courts struck down anti-sodomy laws, a controversial position at the time, but now even some ardent opponents of gay marriage will state they think people should be able to do what they like in their own homes.
Is race becoming more of a problem in America? Hardly. Every new generation becomes more diverse and more racially harmonious than the next. While racist views are passed on from generation to generation, the infection rate is slowly declining, and as more people move into urban settings, or go to diverse colleges, they often begin to relieve themselves of the shackles of hate.
So what makes now different than 2, 10, 20, or 50 years ago? "THE PRESIDENT IS A SOCIALIST!" Well, yes, Conservatives have been saying that about every Democratic President since FDR (who did far more to legitimately earn that title than our current President). The DEFICIT IS EXPLODING! Problem, sure, but the deficit has always been a problem, and will continue to be long after Obama.
So what is it that makes Conservatives like Buchanan or
Rob Huddleston think our days are numbered and the dissolution of our grand experiment is at hand? Simple, wishful thinking. Folks like Buchanan and Huddleston would love nothing more than to see a white conservative oasis free from the shackles of secularism and social welfare. But guess what, its only that, wishful thinking. Sure, some rabble rousers have made their voices heard in town halls and various rallies...but that too is nothing new. People have been shouting, hollering, picketing, and yelling for various forms of radical change for centuries. Communists (and by that I mean people who actually believe themselves to be such) have protested in large numbers during various points of our nation's history, and yet, no communist revolution ever took root.
Remember, the white Southerners have only been out of power for about 3 years, before that, their party held the White House, Senate, US House, and the Supreme Court. Yet, there wasn't any serious talk of states like Vermont or Washington breaking off to start their own country. Sure, liberals would claim in vain that "if Bush wins, I'm going to Canada!" But it was always viewed, and rightfully so, as an idle threat. So, Southern Conservatives (I lump Buchanan in there because of his passionate love of the old South) are doing what they do best. Throwing a hissy fit when things don't go exactly their way. They'll bitch, moan, throw out patriotic slogans while simultaneously threatening to dissolve the country, but at the end of the day, they won't leave their cushy jobs or air-conditioning to do anything more than hold a sign for an hour or so.